5 Reasons Convertible Debt Sucks

Posted by Pierre de la Fortune on August 05, 2015 @ 12:01 a.m.

Written by Furqan Nazeeri

There are two scenarios where convertible debt is typically used: bridge financing and angel financing. Ive raised convertible debt a few times and I have to say that in most angel funding scenarios it sucks as a way to finance a startup (I think its okay for bridge funding, but Id avoid that too if possible). Why?

1) Its complicated.

Many founders think part of the attraction of doing convertible debt is that you get to punt on a lot of the key financing decisions until professional investors do the real work and put a real value on the company. Unfortunately, doing convertible debt requires making a bunch of decisions that in total are about the same complexity as preferred equity. For example, you have to write a loan agreement that includes things like default clauses, collateral, interest rates and more. If the loan is secured (e.g. against the IP) then you have to create a separate lien. Also, its typical to include a discount for the lenders in the form of a warrant, however the warrant is on an equity instrument that does not yet exist (e.g. on the Series A Preferred) but you still need to decide the term of the warrant and the strike price. Also, most founders dont raise all their convertible debt at the same time so they end up with lenders with different warrant coverage (big Excel spreadsheet). Then, when it comes time to close your Series A, you can have a problem where the cap table changes on a daily basis because the interest that accrues on the principal converts as well and that changes daily. [By the way, if you do use convertible debt, I recommend you agree to pay the interest in cash after closing Series A to avoid this last problem.] Add to that caps, collars, failure to convert and all of these issues add up and it makes it more complicated to take convertible debt as opposed to equity.

2) It sets a bad precedent (or at least fails to set a good precedent).

Valuation is just one of the key terms of an investment. I wrote previously on how to evaluate the various terms of an investment. By punting on negotiating the full suite of terms in a round of preferred equity, you are basically leaving it to the Series A investors to negotiate these. And some of them make a big difference (like dividends, preferences, etc.). Most of the time, youre in a much better situation to negotiate favorable (or reasonable) terms with friendly angel investors than you will be with professional VCs My recommendation is to use the opportunity to negotiate favorable terms with angel investors and these will likely become precedent for future rounds.

3) Poor risk adjusted return.

If you run a few scenarios (I have), the potential gain for founders is 3-5% ownership after the Series A round and about half that at a successful exit. If youre lucky enough to get a successful exit of, say $75MM, after raising $15MM of VC and you have 2 founders, youre talking about +/- $500K potential gain each. Now thats a ton of money, but the point here is that in the upside scenario youre looking at a six-figure benefit against which you have to measure and compare the risks. But it makes a big difference in the downside scenario. In a wind-up scenario, the priority of various parties is, from highest to lowest, employees, A/R, secured lenders, preferred equity and common. Yes, founders are at the back of the line, but the secured lenders are slightly ahead of preferred equity.

4) It makes it hard(er) to hire.

When you kick the can down the road on valuation, you then cant agree to split the pie with any specificity. For example, you might hire a new executive with a 2% slice of equity that in just 6 months gets halved or worse. As employees become more savvy to this phenomenon, were starting to see more complex hiring agreements where new hires get full or partial anti-dilution protection. These provisions can quickly eat up the potential founder equity benefit of convertible debt while simultaneously making it even more complicated to raise the first equity round, not to mention the politics of who gets or doesnt get protection.

5) It creates a perverse incentive.

But the biggest problem with convertible debt is that it aligns the interest of your angel investors with future VC investors and against you! Because the debt converts into equity at a price equal to or slightly discounted from what the VCs pay, the lower the price the more the angel investors will own. And often times, the angel investors will have the relationships and connections to VCs (and hence know them better than you do) so it is in your interest to get your angels on your side of the table. Bottom line: convertible debt works best when there is a high likelihood of an equity round happening very soon (i.e. youre bridging a few month gap), but if you are raising angel money and want to use convertible debt to avoid setting a valuation, dont. Raise equity instead.

Is this article helpful?

Comments

Entrepreneurs and how they feel about accounting

Cool site, really dig this shit... -Nadal

Convertible Debt, I am confused already

Why ask why?!?!

wow gold

Make use of it every day to operate Im or her a trainer wow gold http://www.ige.com so nice!! buy wow gold http://www.ige.com as well attractive and actually comes with far from clothing bottoms...Suitable for attending a nightclub subsequent to far too a

եǥ ԩ`֩`

եǥ ԩ`֩` http://ameblo.jp/hivison/entry-11998738353.html եǥ ܩ`ڥ http://ameblo.jp/ribenaa/entry-11998718677.html եǥ ܿgѧ http://ameblo.jp/hivison/e

FENDI rӋ ɥ

FENDI rӋ ɥ http://ameblo.jp/ribenaa/entry-11998719768.html եǥ ޥե` http://ameblo.jp/visonjp/entry-11998728548.html եǥ ֥ http://ameblo.jp/ribenaa/entry-11998724185.html

FENDI ؔ Ů

FENDI ؔ Ů http://ameblo.jp/visonjp/entry-11998733023.html եǥ ԩ``֩` ڥ http://ameblo.jp/hivison/entry-11998735320.html եǥ ؔ ۤ http://ameblo.jp/hivison

asics hyperspeed alternative

You really make it seem really easy together with your presentation but I to find this matter to be really one thing which I believe I'd never understand. It seems too complex and very extensive for me. I am having a look forward for your next submit, I w

hogan collezione 2012

You actually make it appear so easy together with your presentation however I to find this topic to be actually something that I think I might by no means understand. It seems too complicated and very huge for me. I am having a look forward in your subseq

hogan lovells outsourcing

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation however I in finding this topic to be really one thing that I believe I would by no means understand. It kind of feels too complex and very huge for me. I am having a look ahead for your next post, I

hogan knows best knobs

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation however I find this topic to be actually something which I think I might by no means understand. It seems too complex and very broad for me. I'm taking a look ahead in your subsequent submit, I will t

Write something about this article:



Money Blitz Word of the Day

Accounts payable -- amounts owed by the company for the goods or services it has purchased from outside suppliers.

Money Blitz Quote of the Day

The most fundamental winning formula is to bet on human decency and be patient. -Robert Brault

WatchList Quote

Major Index WatchList

EUR & USD Interactive Chart